What do you think? Is Lucious destined to be the anti-hero of Empire forever?
Empire: If we're being honest, I'm kinda over Lucious Lyon
by CHRIS
Empire's Lucious Lyon is basically the worst, and I'm just about ready to write him off
This week's episode of Empire was nothing if
not full of family drama, which speaks to the heart of the show — this
is a family still trying to stitch itself back together following the
matriarch's 17-year absence and, well, a whole lotta other stuff since
she returned. More:18 of Cookie Lyon's best moments on Empire
It's been very clear from the onset that Lucious Lyon is a troubled
man. Brilliant? Yes. Smart? Undoubtedly. Calculating? Always. But
troubled too, and this week's episode did a good job of pulling back the
curtain so we could start to see the real Lucious Lyon.
Which, for the record, isn't even his real name.
Here's where the plot thickens with regard to the head of the Lyon
family. As we had gleaned prior to this point from brief flashbacks,
Lucious' mother was bipolar. What we essentially learned tonight was
that after a manic episode in which she almost drowned him in the tub,
she shot herself right in front of Lucious.
It would have been impossible for such a traumatic event not to
change a child, so some of Lucious' particularly rough edges make a bit
more sense.
However, Lucious' past doesn't justify his behavior in the present.
What happened in his childhood was tragic and devastating and breaks the
heart to think about, but Lucious is now a grown-ass man with the
capacity not to inflict pain in the lives of his own children.
This may be an unpopular opinion but, if we're really being honest, I'm kind of over Lucious Lyon.
As a persona, he's interesting; don't get me wrong. He's fun to
watch, and Terrence Howard — who is kind of abrasive and eccentric IRL —
plays the role right up to the edge of sanity. It's a fascinating
character study.
And if I look back on the first season, I think there were more times
than not I actually rooted for Cookie and Lucious to get back together.
Something about the way his ruthless nature belied such fiercely loyal
and sometimes tender moments was oddly endearing.
Image: Chuck Hodes/FoxMore:A definitive ranking of all the reason Empire's Hakeem won't last long as CEO
If I really think about it, though, I think the thing I've always
liked the most about Lucious is Cookie. Viewing the character through
her empathetic eyes (their history keeps her tethered to him in many
ways) has made me give him the benefit of the doubt thus far.
Let's face it, though: The man has done some seriously shady things
and, above that even, said some deeply hurtful and damaging things to
his own children.
We winced watching flashbacks of his appalling ignorance in his early
interactions with Jamal. Only recently, Lucious used Jamal's sexuality
as a pawn in a bid to beat out his son for an ASA Award.
We saw him steal an artist right from beneath Hakeem's nose and, just
last week, convince Hakeem's ex-lover/boss to commit suicide — and then
suggest to Hakeem it was his fault.
He's lied, he's killed, he's offended, and he's done it all
repeatedly. But it was a fight Lucious had with Andre on this week's
episode that finally pushed me past my threshold for the Lyon
patriarch's deplorable behavior.
After Cookie played the rough cut of Lucious' new autobiographical
music video, Andre realizes his grandmother had bipolar disorder as
well. Naturally, he confronts Lucious about it. As you'll recall,
Lucious has never shown Andre any true respect. He has either largely
ignored Andre's bipolar disorder or he has made Andre feel "crazy." More:Empire's treatment of bipolar disorder strikes me as problematic
During the heated exchange, Lucious says the kind of things you just
can't take back, particularly, "The truth is my mom was a nutjob. I was
embarrassed by her, same way I'm embarrassed by you."
Image: Chuck Hodes/FoxAaaaand I was out.
I'm sure the argument will be made that this type of behavior isn't
out of character for Lucious — that he is a flawed and very complicated
man who has no clue how to love anyone, including himself. Still, I'm
just kind of over it. All of the other characters have experienced
impressive growth between the first season and now... with the exception
of Lucious.
He's still the same selfish ol' asshole he was when we first met him.
If there was any doubt about this fact, it looks as though next
week's episode will at least in part corroborate it when Lucious tries
to sabotage a public appearance by Hakeem. He's becoming so unlikable
that I half-wish he'd go back to jail and get eaten by the ghost of
Frank Gathers.
I'm a huge fan of Empire's writers, so I want to have utter
faith they'll somehow imbue his character with any semblance of a
redemptive quality or moment, but I'm honestly not confident Lucious
Lyon can ever be likable.